What Is a Batch COA is a powerful performance supplement with decades of research to back it up. It’s available in powdered forms, capsules and increasingly in novel delivery formats like gummies. But when it comes to gummy creatine supplements, not all are created equal.

UK-turned-Aussie fitness influencer James Smith recently dropped a bombshell on the industry by paying out of his own pocket to test nine popular creatine gummies in an independent lab. The results were shocking — half of the products he tested did not contain the amount of creatine claimed on the label.

Lab-Tested Creatine Gummies for Quality and Safety

The biggest culprits were DivinusLabs, EcoWise and Happyummmm, which all had trace amounts of creatine at best. To hit a full 5-gram dose, you would have to consume 2,000 gummies from these brands.

The problem lies in the formulation of creatine gummies, according to food biochemist Crystal Webber. She says that even excellent dietary supplement factories often lack the expertise to formulate a gummy that will stay stable, especially when it contains liquids.